Supreme Court stays Troy Davis Execution!

Breaking News: The Supreme Court of the United States, meeting in emergency session, has granted a stay of execution to Troy Davis!  You can find the CNN story here.  The most comprehensive account thus far is by Adam Liptak of the New York Times.

Barring intervention from the federal Supreme Court, Troy Davis will die tonight by lethal injection. The Guardian story explains why Jimmy Carter, Bob Barr, Bishop Desmond Tutu, Amnesty International and the Pope have all begged the state of Georgia to commute Troy Davis’ sentence to life in prison.The article quotes an illiterate Burger King employee who signed a statement written by a police officer even though he had no idea what it said. The officer knew the witness couldn’t read, but had him sign the statement anyway.

Jimmy Carter’s appeal reads: “Executing Troy Davis without a real examination of potentially exonerating evidence risks taking the life of an innocent man and would be a grave miscarriage of justice. The citizens of Georgia should demand the highest standards of proof when our legal system condemns on our behalf a man or woman to die.”

John Lewis, civil rights icon and Congressman from Georgia, has made this statement: “This is a very sad and grave day in the state of Georgia, in our nation and in the world. A man that could really be innocent–and all of the evidence tends to dramatize and quantify that this man may go to his death later today as an innocent human being. And when you commit that final decision and later discover that he is truly, truly innocent of the crime that he’s been accused of committing, there is not any way to bring him back. I just think it’s wrong and it’s unfair, and it will be the greatest miscarriage of justice.”

The Davis case is riddled with question marks and yet the Georgia Supreme Court, with only one dissenting vote, refused to intervene.  Please pray for Troy Davis, his family and his friends.

US state of Georgia urged to halt Troy Davis execution

Mark Tran

guardian.co.uk, Tuesday September 23 2008 12:46 BST

Amnesty International today urged the US state of Georgia to stop the execution of Troy Davis, who faces death by lethal injection tonight despite doubts over his conviction.Las July, the state’s board of pardons and paroles stopped the execution less than 24 hours before it was to be carried out.

However, it yesterday rejected pleas to reconsider its recent decision to deny clemency on the grounds that so much uncertainly exists over whether Davis shot and killed a Savannah police officer.

Georgia’s supreme court also denied Davis’s request for a stay of execution, and his last hope of avoiding execution at 7pm local time (midnight BST) now appears to rest with the US supreme court, where his lawyers have asked for a stay of execution.

In a case that has attracted international attention, Pope Benedict XVI and the former US president Jimmy Carter have asked for the sentence to be commuted to life in prison without parole.

Davis, a 39-year-old African-American, is on death row for the murder of officer Mark MacPhail in 1989, but seven key prosecution witnesses have recanted their testimonies since his 1991 trial and post-trial testimony implicating another man as the gunman has emerged.

A “jailhouse informant” retracted his incriminating account of Davis’ supposed confession, while several other supposed eyewitnesses later took back their trial evidence while insisting they had been under “a lot of pressure” from police to provide signed statements.

One witness, Antoine Williams, a Burger King employee who identified Davis as the gunman at the trial, later said: “Even today, I know that I could not honestly identify with any certainty who shot the officer that night. I couldn’t then either.

“After the officers talked to me, they gave me a statement and told me to sign it. I signed it. I did not read it because I cannot read.”

Chatham County prosecutors, however, are sure that Davis killed MacPhail, who rushed to a Savannah Burger King car park late at night after hearing the screams of a man who was being pistol-whipped.

Prosecutors say that MacPhail, a 27-year-old father of two, was shot down by Davis before he could draw his weapon. They say Davis then stood over the fallen officer and fired again and again.

Davis has admitted being at the scene, but has always denied shooting MacPhail. No physical evidence against him has ever been produced, the murder weapon has never been found and the case against him at trial consisted entirely of witness testimony.

Georgia’s board of pardons says it has extensively studied and considered the case, including hearing from every witness presented by Davis’s lawyers, retesting the state’s evidence and interviewing Davis himself.

“After an exhaustive review of all available information regarding the Troy Davis case, and after considering all possible reasons for granting clemency, the board has determined that clemency is not warranted,” a board spokeswoman told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution newspaper.

Since its resumption of executions in 1977, the US has executed 1,118 prisoners, 42 of them in Georgia.

Meanwhile, more than 100 people have been released from death rows around the country, many in cases in which witness testimony has been exposed as unreliable.

6 thoughts on “Supreme Court stays Troy Davis Execution!

  1. The trial consisted only of witness testimony and then 7 out of 9 recanted? This stinks of an inept and vengeful police force who would rather put an innocent man to death than have an unsolved case. Cops do this all the time. If they can’t get find one person culpable they’ll try to find the first reasonable suspect that they can. It’s almost like teachers reprimanding children in school. ‘If whoever did this doesn’t confess then everyone gets punished.’ Only in this case the punishment is death.

  2. Every one is upset about this killers rights, I say Bull, where are the rights of a Police Officer who was killed in the line of duty??? All those witnesses that recanted did so under oath and should be put in jail for perjury. Jimmy Carter needs to continue to build homes and stay out of Politics, You sir were a pathetic President and need to stop playing one and going to Countries that you have no business!!! I would have put you in jail for impersonation of a President. We don’t need your help and keep your opinions to yourself. I wonder Mr. Carter if you would feel the same way if your stupid brother were killed for his BILLY BEER!!!! I am embarrassed that you were even a Submariner in the U.S. NAVY!!!!!!

  3. Charles, you appear to be assuming the point in question without argument: is Davis really guilty? Jimmy Carter has been America’s greatest ex-President, and evaluations of his work in office have been changing over time. Although Carter admits he wasn’t the most skillful politician, his judgments have stood the test of time. Anyway, Jimmy Carter doesn’t live here, so I would encourage you to take your outrage elsewhere.

Comments are closed.